Showing posts with label 3 Project 4: Re-thinking photojournalism2 - "post-photojournalism". Show all posts
Showing posts with label 3 Project 4: Re-thinking photojournalism2 - "post-photojournalism". Show all posts

Thursday, 21 September 2017

Compassion Fatigue

Source: Campbell, D. (2012) The myth of compassion fatigue. [online] Available at: https://www.david-campbell.org/2012/02/29/the-myth-of-compassion-fatigue/ last accessed 19/9/17

Compassion fatigue is linked to photography because images are used to promote charitable appeals and media coverage shows human suffering.

Compassion fatigue in media and politics is different from compassion fatigue in health and social care (excess of compassion or secondary post-traumatic stress disorder.) Compassion fatigue was defined in the OED in 2012 as:

 “an American term meaning “apathy or indifference towards the suffering of others or to      charitable causes acting on their behalf, typically attributed to numbingly frequent              appeals for assistance’ esp. donations: (hence) a diminishing public response to frequent charitable appeals.”

Cause (numbingly frequent appeals of charities acting on behalf of others)
Effect (apathy / indifference)
Evidence of effect (diminishing public response)

Cohen – populist psychology thesis of compassion fatigue – information overload, desensitisation and normalisation. People respond on individual basis.
How is it perceived that the viewer acts when looking at atrocity pictures? Do we act? Or are we overshadowed by politics? Do we believe in the compassion theory because it fits with what theorists would like to think is happening?

Debate over not responding to crises has been happening for centuries (as early as 1500’s) with claims that photography is an analgaesic (John Taylor), contemporary clichĂ© (Susie Litchfield).

Relationship between imagery and social impact could be described as pornographic (violation of dignity, taking things out of context, exploitation, objectification, putting horror and misery on display, encouragement of voyeurism, construction of desire, unacceptable sexuality, oral and political perversion etc) Argument falls down because although it is assumed that we are subjected to much pornographic imagery (and the voyeuristic side of it makes us want to look) we fail to recognise when we should respond to something portrayed by the media. If we had compassion fatigue, we would have an aversion to seeing the images. Evidence does not match this.

Susan Sontag claimed compassion fatigue existed in On Photography, but by Regarding the Pain of Others, she revoked her argument.

Susan Moeller popularized the theory of Compassion Fatigue with a book in 1999.  “Moeller’s claims to reveal how in her hand ‘compassion fatigue’ is an empty signifier that becomes attached to a range of often contradictory explanations and factors.”

Evidence shows that individuals respond differently to media coverage and it will be issue dependent. “Identifiable victim effect” – if the victim is identifiable people react differently than if the issue is statistics. An image of one person in distress is more effective than two or more or accounts. A sad facial expression gave the viewer “emotional contagion” and sympathy with the victim.

Emotional engagement, on the other hand, allows the individual to look at the context surrounding the victim in more detail. This can negate the need to send donations to the disaster / issue.

18/9/17
BBC posted a video clip entitled “The boy who shocked the world – It has been a year since the suffering of Saleem became the face of Yemen’s suffering. But where is he now?”
A sensational claim of the world being shocked at the 350,000 children in Yemen focussed on Salem, a 6yr old who had severe malnutrition. He was taken to a WHO feeding centre where his malnutrition was treated. The BBC claim the number of starving children has now risen to 2million. The BBC reporter also shares that Salim is now suffering from brain damage and stunted growth.
Researching Salim, he does appear in several papers, just giving, UNICEF etc. There have been updates on his progress and people have given money. UNICEF were half way towards their target last year and the crowd funding doctor nearly reached a fifth of their target before closing the just giving page.

I was surprised that the account was so honest. This seemed to fit with the emotional engagement which Campbell mentions.

The Guardian’s article (Hodal, 2016) mentions compassion fatigue being one of the reasons that people are not giving generously to all the natural and political disasters such as the Yemen food crisis, quoting Moeller to authenticate the arguments. She also suggests that the United Nations is being driven by results and political leaders such as Trump have a part to play in deciding what is funded. However, I have to agree with Campbell’s theory that compassion fatigue is used as an excuse and perhaps to keep the American dream alive?

Bibliography
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/dec/04/un-biggest-aid-appeal-fears-of-compassion-fatigue

Post-photojournalism

Patrick Chauvel, a war photographer of 40 years exhibited Guerre Ici (War here) in Paris (until 2011) and Bayeux. His images fall into the genre of photojournalism although the creative images are contemporary augmented reality. These combined pairs of images (2.5 metres x 2 metres each), displayed the original scene of war from places such as Chechyna, Beirut and Panama which provides the context followed by an interpretation of what could happen in Paris. Initially Chauvel’s collection contained an image of the Twin Towers and the London bombings, but following the two actual terrorist attacks, he removed them.

As a photojournalist, Chauvel “monitor(s) the situation and tells a story.” (Chauvel, 2012) His images illustrate and inform the public what is happening in the war zone. Chauval works on both sides of the war to understand the situation to make informed images (photojournalism). In an interview with Military History (2012), Chauvel clarifies that he works for history books and archives as well as the news. His images carry a warning for people to remember that peace is fragile and war can happen at any time to anyone, providing a means to influence political parties.

It took Chauvel 10 years to be exhibited in Paris because his work was seen as too political or disturbing. However, at the Monnaie de Paris (2011) his work was shown with actual footage of the Liberation in Paris in 1982 from the Paris Match and Michael Wolf’s screen grabs from Google Street View in Paris. Organisers told Chauvel, “You can show real war pictures, but not transpose war into Paris.” (Marzolf, 2015)

By introducing war to a familiar space, the viewer is asked to question what happened if war came to Paris? How do we see war when we are peace? The comments posted on the internet are mixed, although I wouldn’t take this as a real indication of how well his work was received. The websites are mainly in French so translation was a little difficult.

Chauvel addresses the issues of image fatigue by using familiar buildings and landscapes into which he inserts familiar scenes from wars. The colours are fairly dark and smoky reminiscent of painted landscapes by artists such as Turner. By showing the original war scene and then the photomontage, the viewer sees that this is not one particular war; for example, the soldiers’ uniforms are different, but this is an augmented reality which hasn’t happened yet. Because we are used to seeing war portrayed by reporters in action, the viewer look more closely at the image and realise this may not necessarily be a faraway land.

Chauvel was in Paris at the time of the attack on the Bataclan and Café le Carillon (2015). He reacted in the same way as he would when in a war zone, capturing the same facial expressions and emotions on people, with the same symbols such as candles, shrouds etc. This war was different in the fact that it was about freedom rather than religion.

Supposing that footage of a terrorist attack was inserted into a familiar landscape, the viewer might think that the image was too realistic and not see the point that the photographer was trying to make. I think Chauvel’s images have been carefully chosen to fit with the situation, drama, perspective, landscape and allows the viewer to consider war images from their memory in order to start asking questions. There is a danger that the images could be received as fake news but by displaying them in an exhibition with an explanation or on building walls with the original image, the message remains clear.

References
Military History, (2012) Patrick Chauvel an eye for war: the French photographer shot his first war at age 18 and has spent his life depicting the realities of combat. Military History, Nov. 2012, p. 44+.Academic OneFile [online] available at:
go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?p=AONE&sw=w&u=ucca&v=2.1&id=GALE%7CA302463911&it=r&asid=c842ddcc3191e1d3196ed1a92f00c6f8. Accessed 21 Sept. 2017.
Marzolf, H. (2015) Attentats due Paris: Le temoignage du photojournaliste Patrick Cheuvel. [online]  Available at: http://www.telerama.fr/scenes/attentats-de-paris-le-temoignage-du-photojournaliste-patrick-chauvel,134424.php last accessed 21/9/2017

Bibliography
Charuel, M (2011) “Fears over the city” or peace unmasked. Valeurs. [online] Available at: https://www.valeursactuelles.com/societe/peurs-sur-la-ville-ou-la-paix-demasquee-28506 last accessed 21/9/17 last accessed 21/9/17